Hawaii Living

3556 Old Mill Pl (Poipu)

1 / 27
Photo 1 of 3556 Old Mill Pl, Koloa
Photo 2 of 3556 Old Mill Pl, Koloa
Photo 3 of 3556 Old Mill Pl, Koloa
3556 Old Mill Pl, Koloa
Selling or Buying in Poipu?
Fill out the form below and an agent with expertise in Poipu will contact you shortly.
Description
Nearly 18,000 sq. ft. of beautiful land surrounded by the Omao Stream. Quiet, private and serene, yet close to Koloa town and the beaches of Poipu. Two 3-bedroom homes, one made of stone and built in 1947 and the other a renovated classic plantation home built in 1966 with large screened lanai and hot tub. Both homes are in good condition; one is tenant occupied and the other is owner occupied. Beautiful yard with many fruit trees. Outside showers, tool and garden shed and storage. A classic example of old Hawaii. Shown by appointment only.
Past Activity
  • Sep 03, 2025 Listed at $2,355,000
  • Jun 10, 2025 Off Market
  • Feb 18, 2025 Back to Active
  • Nov 15, 2021 Sold for $1,399,000
  • Sep 10, 2021 Under Contract
More Details
  • Owner, Tax & Resale History
  • Price / ft²: $593
  • Zoning: R-4
  • Amenities: Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Microwave, Other, Range, Range Hood, Refrigerator, Washer
  • TMK: 4280060130000
  • Tax Assessed Value: $753,600
  • Courtesy: Oceanfront Sotheby's International Realty / 8086392437
  • MLS: 650892
About Poipu
  • Poipu is a tourism centered area of Kauai, but has retained much of its local feel & Hawaiian heritage. Preserved Ancient Hawaiian sites and celebrations of the plantation past are important foundations of the community.
     
  • The beaches and surrounding scenery made it a desirable place to not only visit, but live. However, the development did not accelerate until the 1980s.
     
  • Much, but not all, of Poipu is a Visitor Destination Area, allowing owners to rent their homes on a vacation rental basis.

Poipu Subdivisions

  ... Read more
MLS properties and information provided herein is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed by the Hawaii Information Service, Inc. Listing Service. © 2026 Hawaii Information Service. All Rights Reserved. This website is for personal, non-commercial use only. Listings last updated on January 04, 2026.
Other Poipu Homes
$1,399,000
2783 Kiahuna Plantation Dr #723
2 Bds | 2 Ba
1,170 ft²
$1,399,000
2783 Kiahuna Plantation Dr #811
2 Bds | 2 Ba
1,170 ft²
$1,425,000
2739 Uluwehi St
4 Bds | 3.5 Ba
3,667 ft²
$1,300,000
3880 Aka Rd
4 Bds | 3 Ba
1,700 ft²
Other Kauai Homes
Kapaa
$1,399,000
4906 Aliali Rd
4 Bds | 4 Ba
2,864 ft²
Lihue
$1,395,000
2509 Kanio St
3 Bds | 2 Ba
1,605 ft²
Kilauea
$1,430,000
4249 Momi St
3 Bds | 2 Ba
1,422 ft²
Kapaa
$1,365,000
5089 Kahana St
2 Bds | 1.5 Ba
964 ft²
Kapaa
$1,350,000
4885 Laipo Rd
3 Bds | 3 Ba
2,007 ft²
Lihue
$1,325,000
2371 Kanio St
3 Bds | 3 Ba
2,682 ft²
  • Sold 11/15/21 at $1,399,000
    (List Price: $1,399,000)
Description
Nearly 18,000 sq. ft. of beautiful land surrounded by the Omao Stream. Quiet, private and serene, yet close to Koloa town and the beaches of Poipu. Two 3-bedroom homes, one made of stone and built in 1947 and the other a renovated classic plantation home built in 1966 with large screened lanai and hot tub. Both homes are in good condition; one is tenant occupied and the other is owner occupied. Beautiful yard with many fruit trees. Outside showers, tool and garden shed and storage. A classic example of old Hawaii. Shown by appointment only.
    MLS properties and information provided herein is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed by the Hawaii Information Service, Inc. Listing Service. © 2026 Hawaii Information Service. All Rights Reserved. This website is for personal, non-commercial use only. Listings last updated on January 04, 2026.
    • Sep 03, 2025 Listed at $2,355,000
    • Jun 10, 2025 Off Market
    • Feb 18, 2025 Back to Active
    • Nov 15, 2021 Sold for $1,399,000
    • Sep 10, 2021 Under Contract
    • Poipu is a tourism centered area of Kauai, but has retained much of its local feel & Hawaiian heritage. Preserved Ancient Hawaiian sites and celebrations of the plantation past are important foundations of the community.
       
    • The beaches and surrounding scenery made it a desirable place to not only visit, but live. However, the development did not accelerate until the 1980s.
       
    • Much, but not all, of Poipu is a Visitor Destination Area, allowing owners to rent their homes on a vacation rental basis.

    Poipu Subdivisions

      ... Read more
    Other Poipu Homes
    $1,399,000
    2783 Kiahuna Plantation Dr #723
    2 Bds | 2 Ba
    1,170 ft²
    $1,399,000
    2783 Kiahuna Plantation Dr #811
    2 Bds | 2 Ba
    1,170 ft²
    $1,425,000
    2739 Uluwehi St
    4 Bds | 3.5 Ba
    3,667 ft²
    $1,300,000
    3880 Aka Rd
    4 Bds | 3 Ba
    1,700 ft²
     
    You do not own the land, but have the right to use the land until an expiration year. At expiration the ownership typically reverts back to the land owner.
    Buyer and Seller have reached an agreement and are under contract. The sale may be subject to one or more contingencies.
    We have handled many transactions for clients who purchase Hawaii real estate without visiting. By request, our network of agents can prepare thorough property videos to ensure you are familiar with every detail necessary. All documents can be signed remotely.
    Buyer and Seller have reached an agreement and are under contract. The sale is expected to close / record soon.
    We will be happy to work with you as a Buyer's agent. Call us to learn more: 808-943-9000.
    Note: A Seller's agent has a fiduciary responsibility towards the Seller. Working with a Buyer's agent objectives and goals are aligned, at no cost to you, the Buyer.
    Other fees could be a special assessment, reserve contributions etc.
    DOM = Days On Market. Our site shows listings immediately. A brand new listing may show DOM 2 or 3 days, if listing agent did not upload the same day listing agreement was executed.
    Includes estimated monthly mortgage payment, maintenance / HOA fees & property taxes. The estimate does not include insurance premiums.
    Learn about property tax rates.