The complex is situated along the pristine sands of Maalaea Bay, popular for swimming, snorkeling, paddling and more. For convenience, an activities office, deli, pub and convenience store are on-site. It is also one of the few Maui vacation rental properties that allow pets.
With 218 one- and two-bedroom units, the complex is spread across two L-shaped, six-story concrete buildings: the Plantation Building, housing even-numbered units, and the Mill Building, with odd-numbered units. Elevators are located at the corners of the buildings. Additional storage is available on-site.
Most one-bedrooms range between 613 and 644 square feet while a few of the two-bedrooms span over 1,200 square feet. Every unit has a lanai, central air conditioning and in-unit washer and dryer. Condos that run parallel to the beach offer unobstructed ocean views, while the rest provide partial views.
Beautifully landscaped, the grounds feature tropical plants like hibiscus flowers and plumeria trees, enhanced by a serene koi fish pond. Located in the center of the complex, the enclosed oceanfront terrace includes a heated pool, wading pool and hot tub. Nearby is a barbecue area with six gas grills plus a putting green.
For convenience, there are two parking lots, one on either side of the complex. One lot is open-air, while the other offers covered parking for some stalls.
Over the past 3 years, an average of 3 fee simple condos sold per year in Sugar Beach Resort. With so few sales, this graph may not fully reflect market trends.
The Sugar Beach Resort graphs use median data points instead of averages, as the median is less affected by extreme outliers and better reflects typical trends.
Sugar Beach Resort Market Summary
(Feb '25 - Jan '26 vs Feb '24 - Jan '25)
$664,000
39.64%
vs $1,100,000 prior 12 months
Median Sales Price
4
100.00%
vs 2 prior 12 months
Number of Sales
86.01%
9.10%
vs 94.62% prior 12 months
List-to-Sale Price Ratio
246
93.70%
vs 127 prior 12 months
Median Days on Market
Thinking of Buying or Selling in Sugar Beach Resort?
Listings appear instantly - new properties added within one minute.
We need your email address, if you would like email alerts. Please Create Account - takes 1 min - or Sign In .
We exclude Leasehold data from this market analysis because Leasehold properties do not compare with regular Fee Simple properties.
We use median instead of the average because it depicts more accurately a central tendency to the sample size. Example: Take 5 numbers - 3, 5, 7, 9, 21. The median is 7 (the middle number) and the average is 9 (sum of all divided by 5).
We count days on market from listing date through closing date.
